In many organizations, it’s the time of year when everyone is busy doing detailed planning for next year so they can finalize budgets. (In fact, I know of at least one org doing all that work right now, despite a fiscal year that doesn’t start until April.)
This kind of annual planning has one glaring issue: The planning takes a lot of time and care, and yet the plans are always wrong.
Why do the most careful plans still get it wrong year after year? Because the kind of ambitious goals worth investing in inevitably take on a big helping of complexity. New target customers. New capabilities. New technologies. New people. Work that requires dependencies across multiple teams. Areas of big uncertainty.
Detailed planning is the wrong approach for big, complex problems. But it’s the only way people know how to build enough confidence to allocate big budgets. Many leaders we talk with feel stuck in that tension.
So, if you’re in the midst of annual planning, looking ahead toward big, ambitious goals, how can you plan in a way that both earns the budget and sets you up for successful delivery?
Here are three key moves we’ve seen work for annual planning in a complex world…
Flip the Budgeting
Instead of plan-estimate-budget, go outcome-budget-forecast-plan.
Start with the outcomes rather than the plans. What business outcomes do you want to create?
Then, consider what a reasonable investment is to achieve that outcome. That’s the proposed budget.
Now, start laying out what you might do to create the outcome and evaluate whether you can do it within the desired investment. We see the best results from a Reference Class Forecasting approach: Compare the future initiatives to past ones to get a sense of what things actually cost. Too many estimates assume the future will always go according to the best case when the past rarely did. This is the first test for whether the budget is likely to be sufficient for the desired outcome.
Balance the Annual Plan’s Two Jobs
Once you’ve tested your big ideas in this way, you’re ready to flesh out the plan a bit more. But it’s important to do this in a complexity-aware way. Complexity-aware annual planning intentionally does two jobs: (1) build more support for the budget request (because detail signals accuracy to our brains, realistic or not) and (2) set yourself up to deliver successfully.
Keeping both these jobs in mind is essential. It’s easy to build a plan that’s overly detailed, making it hard to respond to complexity and change. (Easier than ever, in fact, with LLMs at the ready to generate piles of detail for you.) It’s also easy to build a plan that’s too vague, undermining your credibility with the budget holders.
Build a Complexity-Aware Plan
One of our clients in the finance space had a major goal for 2026 to build the technology to support a new financial product they’d never delivered before. As they worked on the plan for the year, we asked one of our favorite complexity-aware planning questions: “What needs to happen by May so you’re not stressed in October?”
They identified a new calculation that they’d never done before that this tool had to get right. So the specialists who own that math joined at the very start and paired with the vendor’s expert. Pieces nobody would need on day one, like a report that isn’t due until a year after launch, moved down the priority list.
By June, they’d proven the core hypothesis of the initiative. They’d proven they could deliver the most important capabilities. The whole rest of the year was just adding more and more features and getting ready for the big rollout of the new product.
Leaders on the steering committee found themselves in an unfamiliar situation. They were meeting to discuss a big, high-stakes project that was actually going well. There was no crisis to solve!
This wasn’t an accident. By building a complexity-aware plan, this team set themselves up for success. And if it hadn’t gone according to plan, if challenges had emerged in the complex part of the work, that would have happened early in the year and early in the budget, leaving more time and money to respond and pivot.
This kind of plan also threads the needle between too much and too little up-front detail. You can give detail for the approach and content of the first part of the year, focused on the high-value, high-complexity work. And you can keep options open for the back half of the year, planning in larger chunks or even showing multiple possible paths. This communicates that you’ve done your homework, building credibility, without having to say you’re doing user story XYZ in the second sprint of October of next year, which is just too detailed.
Want a reality check on how you’re approaching your 2027 plans before you commit to them? Curious how you can get confidence for October by May? Schedule a free consultation with Humanizing Work today. When you book an intro call with us, you get time with me or Peter for expert advice; we don’t have any sales people you have to work through first. Don’t wait until next year to build plans that can handle complexity.
Last updated